The older USPSTF report has limitations. The finding of overall benefit for 50-59 year old patients is a computer projection based upon a statistical model. The model uses data from subgroups across several trials, and applies the benefits found with aspirin to a hypothetical person - in this case, a 50-59 year-old American male - with a baseline cardiovascular risk estimated using the AHA risk calculator. Unfortunately, that calculator substantially overestimates risk (by anywhere from 20-100% or more).
,s , Given the razor-thin benefit margins found, any overestimate of baseline risk would convert the finding of overall benefit to a finding of overall harm. Moreover, the model is out of date as three new large randomized controlled trials have been published since its release.
There is debate across reviews about the definition of“primary prevention.” In the ETDRS study half of the patients had known CVD, and all patients in the POPADAD study and the AAA study had arterial disease. The USPSTF and older meta-analyses included these studies, Mahmoud et al. excluded them, and Zheng et al. included ETDRS only. These patients constitute less than 9000 subjects (5%) of the total patients analyzed. The varying inclusion of the three studies who enrolled patients with apparent CVD resulted in 96% overlap between the Mahmoud et al. review (157000 subjects) and Zheng et al. review (164000 subjects). The inclusion of some patients with CVD in the Zheng et al. study may explain why Zheng et al. found a statistically significant small stroke prevention benefit, while Mahmoud et al. did not (Table 2).
Less clear are differences in the two new meta-analyses regarding the heterogeneity of the trials. Zheng et al. found no heterogeneity (
I2=0%) for heart attack reduction, while Mahmoud et al. concluded “a high degree” of heterogeneity (
I2=67%). These differences in the results could be from existing heterogeneity among different trials that were included (11 trials in the analysis by Mahmoud et al. and 13 trials in the analysis by Zheng et al.), but more likely reflects differences in the methodology of the meta-analyses.
Regardless of these minor differences, both updated reviews found no consensus finding of benefits outweighing harms in patients regardless of CVD risk, contradicting the statistical model projection from the USPTF report that high-risk subgroups may benefit specifically. While overall benefit may be true in secondary prevention in high-risk patients, results from these primary prevention reviews are uniform in the benefits not outweighing the harms. In fact, the recent ASPREE trial found high-risk patients had increased harm compared to low-risk patients. The proportion of high-risk patients was highest among the newer studies (25-30%), and no statistically significant benefit was found in any outcome—only harms from mortality and bleeding.
, ,
Further concern regarding the USPTF report reliance on the AHA calculator to project a subgroup benefit is that coronary events occurred at less than a third the predicted rate in the ASPREE trial, and less than half predicted in the ARRIVE,and ASCEND trials. In practice, clinicians often apply the AHA calculator used in trials and estimate risk conservatively. If faulty calculators and conservative gestalt lead to overestimation of risk, and clinicians wrongly believe higher risk means greater benefit from aspirin, overall harm due to aspirin prescribing for primary prevention is probably widespread.
By the same token, overestimation means true ultra-high-risk patients (10-year risk of cardiovascular disease >30%) were potentially misdiagnosed as having pre-existing CVD and were not enrolled in primary prevention trials and may potentially benefit. Future studies should tackle this question.
Last but not least, patient preference is an important factor for making the decision regarding aspirin use for primary prevention of cardiovascular disease. Some patients may value avoiding nonfatal heart attacks or possibly avoiding ischemic strokes as being worth the increased risk of major bleeding.
We chose a Red color recommendation (No Benefit) because of consistent findings of harm outweighing benefit. We considered Black (Harmful) but recognize there may be subgroups studies that will identify patients who can benefit.
The original manuscript was published in
Academic Emergency Medicine as part of the partnership between TheNNT.com and AEM.